An atrial septal defect (ASD) is a hole in the wall (septum) between the two upper chambers of the heart, called the atria. This defect allows blood to flow between the left and right atria, which can lead to problems such as increased blood flow to the lungs, right heart enlargement, and sometimes heart failure or arrhythmias if untreated. Fixing an atrial septal defect is important to prevent these complications. This article explains in detail how doctors fix ASDs using different approaches that are both safe and effective.
What Causes an Atrial Septal Defect?
ASDs are usually congenital, meaning they are present from birth. They occur because the septum, which divides the atria during fetal development, does not close completely. There are different types of ASDs, including:
Ostium secundum ASD: The most common type, located in the middle of the atrial septum.
Ostium primum ASD: Located lower in the septum and often associated with other valve defects.
Sinus venosus ASD: Near where the superior vena cava enters the right atrium.
Coronary sinus ASD: Very rare, involves the coronary sinus area.
Each type may require different treatment approaches depending on its size and location.
When Should an Atrial Septal Defect Be Fixed?
Small ASDs may close on their own during childhood. However, moderate to large ASDs usually require treatment to avoid complications. Doctors recommend fixing an ASD when:
- The defect causes significant left-to-right blood shunting
- Right heart enlargement is present
- Symptoms such as shortness of breath, fatigue, or arrhythmias develop
- There is a history of stroke caused by paradoxical embolism
In adults, ASDs discovered later in life also benefit from closure to prevent heart failure or atrial arrhythmias.
Methods to Fix an Atrial Septal Defect
There are two main ways to fix an ASD:
- Catheter-based device closure (transcatheter closure)
- Surgical repair (open-heart surgery)
The choice of method depends on factors like the size and location of the ASD, patient age, anatomy, and presence of other heart conditions.
Transcatheter Device Closure of ASD
This minimally invasive procedure has become the preferred treatment for many patients with suitable ASDs. It involves closing the hole without the need for open-heart surgery. Here is how it works:
A thin tube called a catheter is inserted through a vein, usually in the groin.
The catheter is guided through the blood vessels into the right atrium of the heart.
A special closure device, often made of metal mesh and fabric, is delivered through the catheter.
The device is positioned to cover the defect, sealing the hole between the atria.
Once in place, the device expands to block blood flow through the ASD.
The catheter is then removed, leaving the device inside the heart permanently.
The device acts as a scaffold, allowing heart tissue to grow over it, which eventually closes the defect fully. This procedure typically lasts 1-2 hours and requires only local anesthesia or light sedation. Patients usually recover quickly and can leave the hospital within a day or two.
Who Is Eligible for Transcatheter Closure?
Not all ASDs can be closed with a device. Ideal candidates usually have an ostium secundum ASD that:
- Is moderate to large in size (usually 5-38 mm)
- Has enough surrounding tissue (“rims”) for the device to attach securely
- Has no other complicating heart defects requiring surgery
Patients who have unsuitable anatomy, such as very large ASDs, deficient rims, or other associated heart defects, may need surgical repair instead.
Risks and Benefits of Device Closure
Device closure is generally safe and effective, with benefits including:
- Less pain and quicker recovery than surgery
- No large chest incision
- Shorter hospital stay
Possible risks include:
- Device embolization (rare, device moves from place)
- Arrhythmias
- Residual shunting
- Infection or bleeding at catheter site
Regular follow-up with echocardiography is essential after closure to monitor the device and heart function.
Surgical Repair of Atrial Septal Defect
Surgery is required when the defect is not suitable for catheter closure or if other heart defects need correction. The surgical process includes:
The patient undergoes general anesthesia.
A heart-lung machine is used to take over blood circulation temporarily.
The surgeon opens the chest through a median sternotomy (chest bone incision).
The heart is stopped briefly to allow the surgeon to see inside.
The surgeon repairs the defect either by stitching the hole closed or by placing a patch over it.
The heart is restarted, and the chest is closed.
The patch can be made of the patient’s own pericardium (heart lining) or synthetic material. Surgery typically takes 2-4 hours. Recovery in the hospital usually lasts 5-7 days, with full recovery over several weeks.
When Is Surgery Preferred?
Surgery is recommended for:
- Large ASDs with inadequate rims
- Ostium primum or sinus venosus ASDs
- ASDs with associated valve defects requiring repair
- Patients with multiple or complex cardiac anomalies
Risks and Benefits of Surgical Repair
Surgery carries higher risks than catheter closure but remains very safe with modern techniques. Benefits include:
- Definitive closure of large or complex defects
- Correction of other cardiac problems simultaneously
- Excellent long-term outcomes
Risks may include:
- Bleeding or infection
- Arrhythmias
- Complications related to cardiopulmonary bypass
- Longer hospital stay and recovery time
Post-Procedure Care and Follow-Up
After either device closure or surgery, follow-up is important to ensure proper healing and heart function. This includes:
- Regular echocardiograms to check for residual shunting or device position
- ECG monitoring for arrhythmias
- Endocarditis prophylaxis when recommended (antibiotics before dental or invasive procedures)
- Activity restrictions initially, gradually returning to normal
- Long-term cardiology follow-up for any late complications
Most patients return to normal life without significant limitations after healing.
Alternative and Emerging Techniques
New technologies are improving ASD closure even further. Some include:
New device designs: Smaller, more flexible devices for difficult anatomies.
Robot-assisted surgery: Minimally invasive surgical approaches.
Hybrid procedures: Combining surgical and catheter techniques in complex cases.
Research continues to optimize outcomes and reduce risks.
Conclusion
Fixing an atrial septal defect is critical to prevent long-term problems such as right heart enlargement, arrhythmias, stroke, and heart failure. Treatment choices include transcatheter device closure and surgical repair. The best approach depends on the size, location, and patient-specific factors. Early diagnosis and timely repair lead to excellent results with low risk and improved quality of life.
Patients with suspected or diagnosed ASDs should consult a cardiologist experienced in congenital heart defects. Advances in cardiac care have made fixing ASDs safer and more effective than ever before.
Related topics: